A performance review gives you and each member of staff a set time to look at how the work is going and agree what comes next. Skip reviews and problems sit unspoken until someone resigns or a client complains. Hold them with care and you keep good people and fix small issues before they grow.
Areas to cover in a review
Base the review on the person’s job and the duties you gave them. For most roles that means a mix of measurable results and behaviour. Useful areas include:
- attendance and timekeeping
- following company rules and procedures
- communication with colleagues and customers
- problem-solving and judgement
- teamwork and attitude
Write the standards down before the review period starts, and make them measurable for each person and team. If a security officer works from written assignment instructions, those instructions give you a clear baseline to check patrols and site procedures against.
Feedback through the year
Treat the annual review as a summary. Give feedback through the year, close to the event, so that nothing in the formal meeting surprises the employee. If you raise a lateness problem for the first time at an annual review, the employee will feel ambushed, and you have lost months in which they could have fixed it.
Short, frequent check-ins also take the pressure off the year-end round. You build a record as you go, and you can hold the review as a conversation about patterns in place of a scramble to remember what happened in March. Team meetings help too, because staff hear about each other’s successes and difficulties and understand how their own work fits in.
Give praise when it is due. Staff who see that you notice good work tend to keep it up, and recognition costs you nothing.
Running the review meeting
- Ask for a self-assessment first. Have the employee rate their own performance before you share yours. You learn how they see their work, and you can spend the meeting on the points where your views differ.
- Agree the rating scale. Make sure you and the employee read the scale the same way. Some managers use 1 as the top score and others use 10, so spell it out on the form before you rate anyone.
- Stay specific and positive. Point to examples, such as a clear incident report or a shift missed without notice. Most people don’t make mistakes on purpose, so treat a weak area as a problem the two of you solve together.
- Look for fixes before replacement. Extra training or clearer instructions can often solve a performance problem, which saves you the cost and disruption of recruiting.
- Set objectives. Finish with two or three measurable goals and a date to check progress. The employee leaves knowing what you expect and can work towards it without close supervision.
The return on regular reviews
Regular reviews give staff clear direction and give you a better picture of your team. You find out which people are ready for more responsibility and which need support, and you can plan training around the gaps you see. If you offer rewards, tie them to the standards you set so staff can see the link between their work and the recognition they get.
Employees also tell you things in a review that they would not raise in passing, including where your own management could improve. Ask each person what you could do to help them work better, and act on the answers before the next review comes round. If you don’t hold reviews at the moment, start with a simple form and a short meeting for each member of staff, then build from there.
